Home » My workers or ours? How labor sharing shapes hiring in urban firm clusters: Guest post by Zachary Kuloszewski

My workers or ours? How labor sharing shapes hiring in urban firm clusters: Guest post by Zachary Kuloszewski

by NNW Bureau
0 comments

This is the 11th in this year’s series of posts by PhD students on the job market.

“Who do you work for?” usually has a simple answer: a business, a shop owner, or a family member exclusively hires a worker for an agreed-upon duration. But if you ask this question in a busy workshop, you may hear the names of many different firms or owners. In my job market paper, I break down why the answer to this question can be a bit more complicated in dense, informal labor markets.

Small, informal firms, which employ the majority of workers in sub-Saharan Africa, face many challenges hiring and maintaining an appropriately sized workforce. Worker ability is hard to judge before a worker is on the job, so vetting a new hire is slow and costly. Demand from consumers can vary widely week to week. Firms confronting both issues face the difficult choice of carrying idle labor during slow periods or being left unprepared for peaks in demand. In high-income countries, firms turn to formal temporary agencies. What do firms do in the absence of these formal intermediaries?

In urban Uganda, I survey over 500 firms and 1,000 of their workers to show that firms rely on labor sharing, borrowing workers directly from their competitors, to cope with both high hiring costs and shifting demand. By offering on-demand workers who come pre-verified by a neighboring firm, labor sharing provides flexible capacity, allowing hiring managers to reach across the firm boundary and meet their spikes in demand without sacrificing quality. In effect, skilled workers have a “home firm” but are frequently reallocated to others nearby. In the paper, I combine detailed hiring data with stated choice experiments to estimate an equilibrium model investigating how labor sharing changes hiring and the impacts of labor market policies.

What is labor sharing?

Labor sharing is a distinctive kind of exchange used for temporary work, organized through firm-to-firm relationships rather than an open market. These exchanges have a common structure; they are reciprocal, uncompensated, and owner-coordinated. When one firm receives a large order, the owner requests workers from other same-industry firms nearby, with the borrowing firm paying the shared worker’s wages for the duration of the job, which is often less than a week.

Labor sharing is common and frequently used in the carpentry and metalworking sectors of Kampala, with 80% of firms reporting borrowing a worker from a competitor, and the average sharing firm borrowing or lending about once every ten days. Beyond Uganda, it has been qualitatively documented in Tanzania and Indonesia, where urban markets also feature dense firm clusters. Thus, questions of its structure and impact are important to understanding how small firms (collectively) function in low-income markets.

Labor sharing carries a quality signal and is available on demand

As in many low-income labor markets, workers lack credible signals of quality or skill. Permanent hiring is slow, taking over 4 days to screen a new worker. To examine labor sharing’s role in addressing this screening friction, I elicit firm beliefs about worker characteristics by asking firm owners about worker quality, screening time, and supervision needs. Owners expect 6.3 of 10 hires through labor sharing to make sellable products without further training, higher than any other hiring channel, including social network referrals (p<0.001).  Owners report the least time to screen new shared workers and the fewest hours of supervision, consistent with the idea that borrowing workers avoids high hiring costs, cited by 58% as an advantage of sharing.

Shared workers are also valuable because they are a timely response to short-term, firm-specific demand shocks, which come in the form of large orders. A busy month brings in five times the revenue of a slow month, and over half of owners report that their first response to unexpected demand spikes is to hire via labor sharing.

I combine these market features in the design of stated choice experiments where firms face hypothetical demand shocks and choose between potential extra hires to add to their staff. The experiments show how much firms value specific worker attributes [Figure 1]. I find firms are willing to pay a wage premium of roughly 53,000 Ugandan shillings per week ($14) for a shared worker over a similar walk-in worker. This premium is equivalent to about five years of industry experience, or a third of the median weekly wage.

read more: https://blogs.worldbank.org/en/impactevaluations/my-workers-or-ours–how-labor-sharing-shapes-hiring-in-urban-fir

You may also like