This is the ninth in this year’s job market series.
China has a remarkable development story. Since market-oriented reforms began in 1978, China has rapidly integrated into domestic and international markets, private enterprise has expanded, and GDP growth has averaged over 9 percent annually, lifting nearly 800 million people out of extreme poverty. This transformation, however, followed three decades in which private markets and international economic connections were sharply restricted. What explains the recent rise of market-based capitalism in China? Why were the market reforms so effective?
In my job market paper, co-authored with Jiachen Li, I tackle these important questions by focusing on China’s financial development. I study the emergence of modern financial institutions and show that China’s recent market development has deeper historical roots that predate the Communist takeover in 1949. Specifically, we find that Christian missionaries contributed to the adoption of modern banks prior to 1949, planting the seeds of market-based capitalism that lay dormant during the Communist period but re-emerged as China reopened to markets in the 1980s.
Missionaries’ first objective was conversion. However, their schools and translations of Western texts helped spread the skills and knowledge needed to operate modern banks, especially in the interior, where there was little foreign presence.
What makes modern banks modern and what’s special about missionary education?
Foreign banks introduced modern banking to China in the nineteenth century. Traditional banks in China were mainly kin-based institutions, which relied on personal networks and had unlimited liability. Owners put their personal wealth at risk, which made these banks hard to scale. Modern banks instead were larger corporations with generally limited liability. They could mobilize public deposits at scale and use standardized Western bookkeeping and technologies like the telegraph. Chinese actors used the foreign-bank model to build modern Chinese banks, but they needed the skills and knowledge to be able to start and operate them.
While foreign banks and other foreigners were mostly confined to a few cities and hubs, missionaries reached deep into the interior. Their schools, including ones for adults, offered a new curriculum. Science, mathematics, bookkeeping, and English were among the new things taught, especially by Protestants. This was different from China’s education system, geared towards passing the civil-service examinations. English was very important for becoming a comprador, a Chinese intermediary working in foreign banks. In foreign banks, they could learn financial practices and later bring them to Chinese banks.
Historical period: missionaries contribute to the emergence of modern banks
We digitized and assembled yearly data on financial, economic, and missionary activity spanning 150 years. Our historical sample covers 247 prefectures, administrative areas below provinces and above counties, between 1857 and 1936. Missionary location is not random. We use a staggered difference-in-differences analysis that compares places already reached by missionaries with places not yet reached.
The key assumption is that, without missionary arrival, banking in these places would have followed similar trends. We find no systematic pre-trends in banking and other economic outcomes.
We find that missionary arrival increases modern-bank offices by about 31% and, with a delay, enterprises by about 27%. The banking effect builds gradually after mission entry (Figure 2a), while the enterprise response emerges about five years later. Our interpretation is that part of the missionary effect on enterprises could be downstream of banks.
Why would missionaries affect banks?
We test this hypothesis in a few ways:
· Banker biographies. Using biographies of Chinese bankers that we digitized, we identify bankers with Christian-school backgrounds or other Christian connections. These bankers account for roughly 27% of the bankers active between 1840 and 1936 in our data, and their local share rises after missionary arrival.
· Schools and Protestant missions. The banking response is stronger in places with missionary schools and is driven by Protestant rather than Catholic missions, consistent with Protestant missions’ emphasis on schooling.
· Publications and printing presses. Missionaries produced and translated educational, scientific, and economic materials into Chinese. The effect of missionary activity on modern banks is substantially larger where missionaries operated publications or printing presses.