Home » Can religion bridge ethnic divides? How pastors in the DRC promote collective action where chiefs cannot: Guest post by Gabriel Granato

Can religion bridge ethnic divides? How pastors in the DRC promote collective action where chiefs cannot: Guest post by Gabriel Granato

by NNW Bureau
0 comments

This is the seventh in this year’s job market series.

Where governments lack resources for basic infrastructure, communities rely on informal arrangements to organize contributions of labor, money, and materials to maintain public goods. Yet, sustaining individual contributions can be challenging in ethnically diverse settings, as such divisions may create obstacles to enforcing social sanctions that prevent residents from free-riding on neighbors’ contributions. In principle, local leaders could help solve this enforcement problem. But chiefs, the authorities best placed to do so, also have their influence constrained by ethnicity. Who, then, can bridge ethnic divides?

Religious leaders are natural candidates. In large parts of the developing world, they play important roles—from conflict resolution to job training to service provision—and are central to many communities’ livelihoods. Importantly, they differ from chiefs in two crucial ways. Their scope of authority extends beyond the ethnic group, and research has documented a correlation between moralizing religions and cooperation. Second, rather than relying on social sanctions, religious leaders can appeal to internal religious motives (e.g., fear of divine judgment) that do not require an audience of peers.

Our paper tests whether this intuition holds: can religious leaders sustain cooperation where ethnic divisions limit chiefs’ influence? Would a shared faith be enough to induce costly contributions across ethnic lines? And would chiefs really fail to enforce contributions from residents of other origins? We cannot answer these questions by comparing existing communities: apparently effective leaders might simply have more cooperative residents.

Randomizing collective action in Kananga

To test whether religious leaders can sustain cooperation where ethnic divisions limit chiefs’ influence, we partnered with the city administration of Kananga, in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), during a campaign to encourage participation in salongo—a longstanding community-labor institution in which residents repair roads, remove waste, and protect neighborhoods from erosion (Figure 1, top).

As part of the campaign, the administration introduced a contribution-tracking system and organized volunteer teams for public maintenance over several weeks. We helped implement the program and randomly assigned teams to include a chief, a pastor, or no leader. We also varied whether teams assembled residents who shared the chief’s ethno-territorial origin (homogeneous) or came from different origins (mixed). The experiment covered 1,040 participants across 336 teams.

read more: https://blogs.worldbank.org/en/impactevaluations/can-religion-bridge-ethnic-divides–how-pastors-in-the-drc-promo

You may also like